Melissa Todd: A battle of two halves on the BBC

Melissa and Daisy feature in the BBC’s Crossing Divides series

One Monday morning this month I got a phone call from a BBC researcher. She asked if I’d like to be on telly to defend a column about DFLs (Down from London) I wrote last year, as part of my debate series with the inestimable Matthew Munson. You can read it here Matthew won that vote, although now my poisonous, inflammatory views have got me on telly, I think it’s pretty obvious who’s the real winner.

I was in a beautician’s chair having my face stabbed with a 540 needled dermo-roller when Lauren rang. If only she’d made the call five minutes earlier I’d have skipped the stabbing: while it’s splendid for acne scarring, it does tend to leave one rather blotchy and mottled for the next week or so, not a look I’d choose for a TV appearance. Plus, I could barely hear her over the whirr of needles piercing flesh and my own resultant screams. Nor indeed, concentrate.

“What’s that? Go on telly to tell a beautiful young artist why she’s all that’s wrong with Margate and should clear off back to where she came from? Well, I don’t see how that could possibly backfire. I’m in!”

The piece was being created for the BBC’s Crossing Divides season, which looks at how society has fractured along age-old fault lines like class, race, religion, politics, and how connections may yet be made and social cohesion restored. Here, then, was an open goal: a hoary old Thanetian like me, utterly opposed to all forms of creativity, taking on some fey, arty, Johnny-come-lately, type.

Except I run a theatre company, write a bit and hail from Hertfordshire, while Daisy, my opponent, has actually lived in Thanet since childhood. And we agreed on almost everything, so our encounter didn’t quite go to script.

We met at the Two Halves pub in Margate: apparently the BBC, like myself,  can’t resist a blindingly obvious metaphor. It was cleared of disgruntled drinkers by two beefy cameramen, the whole bar being needed to house my mottled face and swollen ego. “See, this is exactly what I mean, wretched DFLs, coming down here, turning honest working people out of their usual drinking hole of a Friday night! What an overgrown sense of entitlement, what outrageous arrogance!” I messaged  to my husband, while smiling brightly at the director. Like most keyboard warriors, I’m a good deal more cowardly and conciliatory in the flesh.

I think I did OK. There were a few points I wanted to make that melted from my brain under the studio lights’ glare. For instance, yes, I am aware how absurd I sound championing working class culture in my ridiculously posh voice.

But also, I wish I’d said that when working class culture becomes something risible, inferior, something to be swept away and replaced, a new form of identity will often rush in to fill the void: indeed, it isn’t too fanciful, I believe, to suggest that the rise of the far right is related to this trend. The gentrification and homogenisation of social mores,  the dominance of the metropolitan elite, are leaving the working classes socially and culturally homeless, and more inclined than ever to cleave to strong but loathsome identities, the EDL, Tommy Robinson and his thugs. Now it’s no longer acceptable to colonise and lampoon other countries, we are doing it to certain of our own British sub-cultures. It’s outrageous. And dangerous.

I didn’t make that excellent point, however, because I was too busy staring at Daisy and thinking, jeez, she’s so pretty. So pretty and so young. I’m going to look like her granny. And worse, she’s so nice I can’t even hate her. Why did I ever agree to this torment? Curse my wretched craving for attention!

The BBC only had one SD card in their entire outfit, (the license fee isn’t enough, it seems) and Daisy and I talked A LOT, so we had only 90 seconds to each say what we’d learned from the encounter, then chink our two halves of beer cheesily to end the piece. I’d learned that some DFLs are really trying to reach out to disadvantaged local youngsters: she’d learned that the Turner can be a terrifying, confusing place if contemporary art isn’t part of your milieu.

The piece will air in April. Once I’ve seen how bad my face looks, maybe I’ll post a link.


  1. Hilarious! How long do you have to have been DOWN HERE to count as local? put in 28 years now and still think you all talk posh

  2. I’m with you, Melissa.

    But it’s not just the working classes who object to the seemingly unstoppable take-over by the so-called “metropolitan elite”.

    The posing, self-satisfied, look-at-us-aren’t-we-cool brigade are an offence to all of us who believe the area could be sustained and improved by sensible planning, realistic economic policies and hard work.

    Thanet should not be a plaything for gadflies who will eventually move on to the next hipsters’ hotspot.

    • Excellent article, Melissa. And I agree with Mike, above. I actually misread his comment about places being eminently improveable by sensible planning. I saw “sensible planting”. I think we’re both right 🙂

  3. I don’t know what has shaped this new breed from London that have come to Margate but they’re nothing like the real down-to-earth working – class Londoners that I know. They’re a pretentious, superficial and snobby bunch, self satisfied and smug. They’ve contributed nothing to this area apart from pollution, overcrowding, cliquey yoga studios and cafes and inflated
    property prices. They go on about the joys of Thanet but my guess is that they’re enjoying the freedom that their capitalist investments have brought them and they live in their ivory towers looking down on the locals whom they have priced out of the market.

Comments are closed.